Baseball Crank
Covering the Front and Back Pages of the Newspaper
February 16, 2012
BASEBALL: RIP Gary Carter

Age 57. The brain tumors got the third strike past him that Calvin Schiraldi never could. A good man and a great ballplayer, gone too soon.

1980-topps-70-gary-carter.jpg

I put Carter in context in my Hall of Fame catchers column in 2009:

Gary Carter carried the heaviest catching workload of anybody whose prime spans eight or more years - a staggering 144 games caught per 162 team games (and this for a team, in Montreal, that often stacked up doubleheaders in August due to April snow-outs). If you watched Carter at the tail end of those years and the seasons that followed, you saw what a brutal toll the workload took on his body, as every aspect of his game unraveled. Carter is the classic guy whose numbers make more sense when you extract his prime from the wreckage that followed. Besides being a devastating power hitter, Carter was a very tough guy to run on until his last year in Montreal, and in an age when base thieving was running rampant in the National League. In New York he also mentored a talented young pitching staff, or rather shared that role with Keith Hernandez.

As I noted in that column, over the decade of his prime from 1977-86, Carter caught 38.5% of base thieves, while facing an enormous volume of opposing stolen base attempts. And while carrying that heavy defensive load, Carter averaged .274/.347/.474 with 26 HR and 92 RBI. I'd rank Carter behind Josh Gibson, Johnny Bench, Yogi Berra, and Mickey Cochrane, and maybe Mike Piazza given how much better a hitter Piazza was than Carter or any other catcher. But you'd have a hard time finding anybody else with a good case to rank above Carter (I'd put him ahead of Campanella, Dickey, Fisk, Pudge Rodriguez, Simmons and Posada), which in my book makes him the 5th best catcher in MLB history (given that Gibson never played in the majors).

Carter was baseball's Tim Tebow before there was a Tim Tebow - a cheery Christian off the field, tough as nails on it. Carter was the ultimate guy who never backed down, never gave up, never begged out. I loved, loved John Stearns as a kid; Carter had Stearns' toughness with more talent. He battled Stearns to a draw in home plate fight around 1978 or so. In the famous 1986 Mets-Reds brawl, after Ray Knight clocked Eric Davis, Carter took Davis out of the fight by tackling him with his mask under Davis' ribs, knocking the wind out of him.

Carter, of course, arrived with a bang in New York. His first game as a Met, April 9, 1985, he caught the whole game and hit a game-winning walkoff homer in the 10th inning against the Cardinals. His second game, two days later, he caught all 11 innings of a 2-1 win against the Cards. His third game, the next day, he homered in a 1-0 win. He caught the next day (another win), then homered and drove in two runs while catching a 4-0 win the following day. And yet Carter would get better: the last 62 games that year, while catching a young staff including the incomparable season by Dwight Gooden, Carter hit .300/.367/.599 with 21 HR and 59 RBI, while striking out just 18 times (this included his 5 homers in two days rampage in San Diego in September. This after a 1984 season when Carter became one of just four catchers (the others being Bench, Campanella and Darren Daulton) to lead the league in RBI.

By 1988, Carter was a shell of his former self, with his months-long home run drought stuck at 299 career homers a sad joke. But he still had one last great moment left, when he doubled in the winning runs in a 3-run rally in the ninth inning of Game One of the LCS, the Mets rallying to win after Daryl Strawberry snapped Orel Hershiser's scoreless streak earlier that inning.

Rest in Peace, Kid. Thanks for the memories.

UPDATE: Gus Ramsey has a great story about Carter at the Hall of Fame.

SECOND UPDATE: An emotional Keith Hernandez breaks down on air. Keith's a cool customer by nature, but this is what we're all feeling.

How tough was Carter? People forget exactly how many doubleheaders the Expos played in those days because of early season snow. From 1977-83, Gary Carter caught both ends of a doubleheader 40 times in 7 years (I counted games in the game log where he entered the game as a catcher and caught a few innings). In 1978, Carter caught both ends of ten doubleheaders. Ten. In September 1979, Carter caught both ends of a doubleheader 6 times in 13 days. In September 1981, Carter caught both ends of doubleheaders on consecutive days.

Carter drove in 101 runs in 1980 batting behind tablesetters who hit .257/.337/.363 and .224/.307/.293. In 1984, he led the league in RBI hitting behind a guy with a .301 OBP, on a team whose leadoff hitter was 43 years old, slow, and hit .259/.334/.295.

Posted by Baseball Crank at 5:40 PM | Baseball 2012-13 | Comments (4) | TrackBack (0)
Comments

Crank, I think you actually ranked Kid Carter too low.

For the life of me, I cannot find a measurable difference when comparing Gary. Carter to Johnny Bench. Based upon the fact that many folks deem Bench the top backstop of all time, what does that say about Carter?

5-year peaks? Carter had 31.6 WAR (baseball reference) from 1982-1986. Bench during his 5 year peak from 1970-1974 had 31.9 WAR.

How about a 9 year peak? From 1977 to 1985, Kid had 54.2 WAR. From 1969-1977, Bench had 53.1 WAR.

Bench had a clear advantage in throwing out base runners, but Carter's career defensive WAR is 10, while Bench's was 6.5. Carter had 124 career defensive Wins Shares to Bench's 100.

Carter's 10-year peak ('77-'86) Offensive Winning Percentage was .614, while Bench's ('68-'77) was .617.

In fact, the only reason Bench's career offensive numbers are a bit better than Carter's is that his post-peak period was longer and more productive. And that's it. (As you've pointed out in the past, players aren't penalized or rewarded for the counting stats they accumulate after their peak years...)

The point? Well, if Bench is the top catcher of all time, then Carter's in the running for that title, too.

I'm a Cincinnati guy, and it pained me to analyze this stuff. However, Kid was better than Yogi, because Bench smokes Yogi using the above comparisons. Gibson is too hard to analyze at this point and Campanella's career was too short. Who's left? Cochrane and Piazza? My hunch is that Carter's numbers are better than the former. Piazza was the greatest hitting catcher, but no one combined the defense and offense like Bench and Carter...

If the Kid isn't one of the top 3 catchers of all time, I'll eat my old first baseman's mitt in the basement...

God's speed, Kid...

Posted by: Hooligan at February 16, 2012 6:58 PM

Always thought Carter was a good guy and the best catcher of his era. That being said with all the '86 highlight footage going on I would like Bucky Dent and Aaron Boone to check into high security hospitals for the next few days just to make sure.

Posted by: jim at February 17, 2012 2:22 AM

Carter spent most of his good years in relative obscurity in Montreal, which guys like Bench and Berra played on some of the greatest teams ever, giving everybody who watched baseball many, many opportunities to see them at their best. By the time that Carter moved to NY, he was clearly on the downside. I think that greatly affects how he is generally perceived.

I've been a Met fan since the John Stearns (Maz, Kingman, Youngblood, Flynn, Swan, Allen, etc.) days too, and my memories of Carter are some of the highlights like getting the 9th Inning of Game 6 starter. But my kind-of overall feeling about him as a player was as a somewhat over-the-hill guy, with a lot of strikeouts -- simply because that's where he was in his career when I really got to know him.

RIP, Kid.

Posted by: A.S. at February 17, 2012 9:18 AM

Godspeed from a lifelong Dodger fan to a worthy and dangerous opponent, and a well-qualified Hall of Famer. We'll miss you.

Posted by: MSE at February 17, 2012 8:52 PM
Site Meter 250wde_2004WeblogAwards_BestSports.jpg